CA Ankit Gulgulia (Jain)

By CA Ankit Gulgulia (Jain)

Published on November 16, 2026

Under the old Income-tax Act, 1961, a long-standing legal battle was settled by landmark judicial precedents allowing rollover exemptions under Section 54EC for depreciable assets (like buildings or machinery) held for more than the threshold period, even though Section 50 treated those gains as short-term for computation.

With the framework of the new Income Tax Act, 2025 a subtle structural shift threatens this position. Here is a crisp breakdown of the law, the conflict, and the key judgments.

1. The Legal Conflict: Character vs. Computation

  • The Old Act (Section 50 & 54EC): Section 50 created a legal fiction treating capital gains arising from depreciable blocks of assets as Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG). However, courts held that this fiction was restricted strictly to the computation of capital gains, and did not strip the underlying asset of its long-term capital asset character if it was held beyond the qualifying period.

  • The New Act Shift: The phrasing in corresponding provisions of Section 85 of Income Tax Act, 2025 alters the trigger from the transfer of a “long-term capital asset” to the arising of “long-term capital gains”. Because block-of-asset gains are statutorily categorized as short-term, this shift can technically disqualify taxpayers from claiming the exemption.

2. Key Landmark Judgments (Under the Old Act)

  • CIT v. V.S. Dempo & Co. Ltd. [2016] 387 ITR 354 (SC): The Supreme Court held that Section 50 is only a machinery provision for computation. If a depreciable asset is held for more than the required period, it remains a long-term capital asset, making the assessee eligible for capital gain exemptions.

  • CIT v. Ace Builders (P.) Ltd. [2005] 281 ITR 210 (Bom): The Bombay High Court ruled that a long-term depreciable asset yielding short-term capital gains under Section 50 can still qualify for rollover relief (historically under Section 54EC/54E) because the asset’s inherent nature does not change.

Summary Takeaway

While judicial interpretation under the old regime heavily protected taxpayers by separating the computation fiction (Short-Term Capital Gain) from the nature of the asset (Long-Term Capital Asset), the revised wording under the new tax framework requires careful evaluation. Taxpayers dealing with block-of-asset transfers must reassess their long-term reinvestment strategies to avoid unexpected disallowances.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest