CA Ankit Gulgulia (Jain)

By CA Ankit Gulgulia (Jain)

Published on November 20, 2026

Based on the draft Agenda Note circulated by the CBIC GST Policy Wing (File No. CBIC-20006/77/2026-GST, November 2026) for the Standing Committee of Officers (Bare Copy Refer to Bottom of this Post)

Introduction

For years, one provision of the CGST Act has caused sleepless nights for honest businesses: section 16(2)(c). It makes a buyer’s input tax credit (ITC) depend on whether the supplier has actually paid the tax to the Government. A buyer who holds a valid invoice, has received the goods, has paid the supplier in full and has filed returns can still lose credit because someone upstream in the supply chain defaulted.

A draft Agenda Note now prepared by the GST Policy Wing of CBIC, and sent to the GST Council Secretariat to be placed before the Standing Committee of Officers, proposes a balanced fix. It has three main parts:

  1. Relax the wording of section 16(2)(c) so that the recipient is no longer concerned with how the supplier paid the tax (cash or credit).
  2. Tighten section 16(2)(b) so that goods or services must be received from the same supplier who issued the invoice.
  3. Insert a new section 16A that expressly denies ITC to a recipient who is shown, through an investigation, to have knowingly participated in a fake-invoicing chain.

This article explains the background, the proposals, the case law behind them and what taxpayers should make of them. Important: this is a draft agenda note for deliberation. It is not yet law. It needs Council recommendation and then an amendment to the CGST Act by Parliament before it takes effect, and the final text may change.

Background: the problem with section 16(2)(c)

Section 16(2) says a registered person is not entitled to ITC on any supply unless a set of conditions is met. These include possession of a tax invoice or debit note, the supplier’s reporting of the invoice in the statement of outward supplies (GSTR-1), actual receipt of the goods or services, the ITC details communicated under section 38 not being restricted, and the filing of the return under section 39.

The condition at the heart of the controversy is clause (c). In its present form it reads that, subject to section 41, the tax charged on the supply must have been actually paid to the Government, either in cash or through utilisation of input tax credit admissible in respect of the said supply.

Why it hurts bona fide buyers

The Agenda Note points out the practical difficulty. Under the present return filing system, a supplier does not pay tax invoice-wise. The tax liability for a month is aggregated and discharged partly through the electronic cash ledger and partly through the electronic credit ledger. A recipient therefore cannot find out:

  • whether the tax on a particular invoice was paid in cash or through ITC; or
  • whether the ITC used by the supplier was itself admissible.

The GST portal gives the recipient no facility to check these facts. As the note puts it, the condition makes the recipient’s credit depend on facts that are neither known to him nor within his control.

How sections 41 and 155 fit in

Section 41 entitles every registered person, subject to prescribed conditions, to avail eligible ITC as self-assessed in the return. Where the supplier has not paid the tax, the recipient has to reverse the credit with interest under section 41(2) and can re-avail it when the supplier pays, in the manner provided in rule 37A of the CGST Rules, 2017. Section 155 places the burden of proving the eligibility for ITC on the person claiming it.

What the GST Council discussed at its 57th meeting

Agenda Item No. 3(tt) of the 57th GST Council meeting had proposed omitting the words “either in cash or through utilisation of input tax credit admissible in respect of the said supply” from section 16(2)(c). The idea was simple: a recipient’s credit should not be denied merely because the ITC used by his supplier, or anyone further up the chain, is later found to be inadmissible. The recipient has no means of verifying that.

The discussion in the Council brought out the following views:

  • Maharashtra said it fully appreciated that a genuine taxpayer who has paid the tax should not be penalised for somebody else’s default. It suggested that a mechanism be worked out to identify the defaulter in the chain and recover the tax from him, so there is no revenue loss and the honest payer is not penalised.
  • Karnataka supported this, said it favoured improvement and rationalisation of the provision to help genuine businesses that pay the price for another’s fault, and referred to the guidelines laid down by the Punjab and Haryana High Court on invoking section 16(2)(c). It said it was open to working on a better solution.
  • The States generally felt there must be a proper mechanism to deal with persons who knowingly collude to defraud the exchequer.

The Council therefore decided that a Committee of Officers should come out with a framework or a better alternative within three months, to be shared with the States before being placed before the Council.

Separately, before the 57th meeting, the State of Odisha had suggested that clause (b) of section 16(2) be improved to provide that the goods or services must have been received from the said supplier.

What the courts have said

The Agenda Note builds its case on three strands of jurisprudence.

1. Gujarat High Court: Maruti Enterprise vs. Union of India (2026) 42 CENTAX 256 (Guj.) [01.05.2026]

The Court declined to read down section 16(2)(c) and upheld it. But in paragraph 87 it observed that the Government is not helpless against a seller who has not paid tax. The Act gives the authorities enough power to proceed against the selling dealer, and sections 73 and 74 let the department proceed against defaulting parties for non-payment, short payment and wrongful utilisation of credit. The Court called for a balanced approach based on the principle of the European Court of Justice in Axel Kittel: availment of ITC can be denied only if it is shown that the recipient knew or ought to have known that the purchase was connected with fraudulent tax evasion. The Court also expected the Government to address the issue of genuine purchasers.

2. Punjab and Haryana High Court: Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of Punjab (CWP-34296-2024) [01.10.2026]

The Court also upheld the provision’s validity but held that it cannot be invoked in a routine or mechanical manner. At the same time, cases of collusion, fraud, a non-existent selling dealer, goods or services not actually received, or other circumstances that make the ITC claim inadmissible stand on a different footing. In such cases the issue is not just the supplier’s subsequent non-payment but the recipient’s underlying entitlement to ITC.

The Court also laid down guidelines for invoking section 16(2)(c). In summary:

  • Cancellation of the selling dealer’s registration may be the starting point of an inquiry but cannot by itself be the basis for denying credit.
  • The investigation should establish a direct link between the recipient and the supplier.
  • The supplier’s fraud should not be attributed to the purchasing dealer unless facts connecting him with the fraud are disclosed in the notice.

3. The VAT-era position

Under the earlier VAT regime, High Courts consistently held that a purchasing dealer who transacted bona fide with a validly registered seller could not be denied ITC merely because the seller failed to deposit the tax. The Department’s remedy lay against the defaulting seller.

  • In On Quest Merchandising India (P.) Ltd. v. Government of NCT of Delhi {2018 (10) GSTL 182 (Del.)}, the Delhi High Court read down section 9(2)(g) of the Delhi VAT Act, 2004, because the purchaser was being asked to do the impossible. Collusion between dealers was left to be handled separately under section 40A of the DVAT Act. The Supreme Court declined to interfere in Commissioner of Trade & Taxes v. Arise India Ltd. {2022 (60) GSTL 215 (SC)}, with liberty to the Revenue to pursue cases where transactions were not bona fide.
  • The same principle was followed in Shanti Kiran India (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner, Trade and Tax {(2025) 35 Centax 222 (S.C.)}, where the Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeals, noting that the selling dealer was registered on the date of the transaction and that neither the transactions nor the invoices had been doubted on inquiry.

The settled position under VAT, as the note summarises it, was that a bona fide recipient is not to be acted against for the supplier’s default, and that action lies first against the defaulting supplier.

International practice

The European Court of Justice in Axel Kittel vs. Belgian State (C-439/04 and C-440/04) [06.07.2006] held that a taxable person who did not know, and could not have known, that his transaction was connected with the seller’s fraud cannot be denied the right to deduct input VAT. But where objective factors show he knew or should have known that he was taking part in a transaction connected with fraudulent evasion of VAT, the right to deduct is to be refused. In the United Kingdom this is applied by examining the taxable person’s general awareness, the contrived features of the transaction chain and whether warning signs from due diligence were ignored.

The proposals in detail

The Agenda Note concludes that the 57th meeting’s proposal to drop the “cash or ITC” words is desirable because the recipient has no control over, or visibility into, those facts. It also recognises the tax administrations’ legitimate concern that those who knowingly collude to defraud the exchequer should not get the benefit of ITC. Such cases, as the Punjab and Haryana High Court noted, go to the root of the recipient’s entitlement.

The note’s reasoning is that a recipient can be held responsible for the actions of his immediate supplier, but cannot be asked to reverse ITC because of a default by a supplier at any stage of the chain when he himself is not involved in the violation. The present law, however, has no express provision for denying ITC where the recipient is involved in a fraudulent supply chain. Hence the package below.

Proposal 1: Amend section 16(2)(b)

Present text: he has received the goods or services or both.

Proposed text: he has received the goods or services or both from the said supplier.

The purpose, following Odisha’s suggestion, is to ensure that goods or services have been received from the very supplier who issued the invoice. This addresses cases where goods come from one person while the invoice is obtained from another.

Proposal 2: Amend section 16(2)(c)

Proposed text: subject to the provisions of section 41, the tax charged in respect of such supply has been paid to the Government; and

Two changes are visible in the draft. The words “either in cash or through utilisation of input tax credit admissible in respect of the said supply” are omitted, and the word “actually” is also struck out. The condition that the tax be paid to the Government by the immediate supplier is retained. That keeps first-stage payment protected, which the note says is in line with the Gujarat High Court’s reasoning in Maruti Enterprise.

Proposal 3: Insert section 16A

A new section 16A is proposed in Chapter V. In substance, it provides that, notwithstanding anything contained in the Chapter, a registered person shall not be entitled to take ITC in respect of any supply of goods or services or both where it is established through an investigation that such registered person has:

  • knowingly assisted, or
  • knowingly been involved or concerned in, or
  • knowingly been a party to,

the issuance of an invoice or bill without supply of goods or services or both, in respect of the said supply or at any antecedent stage within the chain of supply relating to the said goods or services or both.

Three features stand out:

  • Knowledge is the trigger. Honest ignorance is not enough to attract denial. The provision is aimed at deliberate participation.
  • An investigation is mandatory. The note says that, as a safeguard and in line with the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s principles, involvement must be established through a process of investigation.
  • It reaches the whole chain. The denial applies where the recipient was knowingly involved in fake invoicing at any antecedent stage, not just at the immediate supplier level.

Being placed in Chapter V, section 16A would operate as an additional condition of eligibility, to be read with sections 16, 41 and 155.

Consequential changes to sections 41 and 155

To bring in specificity, the note also proposes these amendments:

Section Proposed wording
Section 41(1), availment of ITC Every registered person shall, subject to such conditions and restrictions as may be specified in Chapter V, be entitled to avail the credit of eligible input tax, as self-assessed, in his return, and such amount shall be credited to his electronic credit ledger.
Section 155, burden of proof Where any person claims that he is eligible for input tax credit under Chapter V, the burden of proving such claim shall lie on such person.

The effect is to tie both provisions expressly to the conditions in Chapter V, which will now include section 16A. The note also clarifies that the proposal does not affect the proper officer’s powers to recover tax from the defaulting supplier under the Act.

What changes for taxpayers

Aspect Present position Proposed position
Mode of supplier’s payment Tax must be paid “in cash or through utilisation of admissible ITC” Only payment of tax to the Government by the supplier is required; the mode is irrelevant
Inadmissible ITC used upstream Recipient’s credit is exposed Not a ground to deny the recipient’s credit by itself
Receipt of goods or services Receipt of goods or services only Receipt must be from the invoicing supplier
Fraud by the recipient No express denial provision in section 16 Express denial under section 16A after investigation and on proof of knowing involvement
Recovery from defaulter Available under the Act Unaffected

Who benefits

Bona fide buyers, especially MSMEs and traders who deal with many suppliers and have no way of checking how each supplier pays its tax, stand to gain the most. The proposal also reduces the risk of demands raised mechanically on the basis of a supplier’s cancelled registration or return default.

Where caution is needed

  • Receipt from the said supplier. The amended clause (b) will make it important to maintain proper records, such as transport documents, e-way bills, delivery proof and payment trails, that connect the goods or services to the invoicing supplier. Situations involving drop shipments, bill-to/ship-to arrangements or third-party logistics will need careful documentation.
  • Immediate supplier’s payment still matters. The relief covers the mode of payment and defaults at earlier stages. The condition that the tax charged on the supply be paid to the Government continues, subject to section 41 and the reversal and re-availment mechanism under rule 37A.
  • Burden of proof remains on the claimant. Section 155 stays, and the proposed change ties it to Chapter V. Businesses should be ready to prove the genuineness of transactions.
  • Due diligence. The note itself refers to international practice under which ignoring warning signs weighs against the recipient. Although section 16A as drafted turns on knowing involvement, it is sensible to carry out supplier due diligence, such as verifying registration status, return filing compliance, reasonableness of pricing and the real capacity of the supplier to supply.

Points to watch as the proposal moves forward

  • Statutory status. The note is for deliberation by the Standing Committee of Officers. The Council must still recommend the changes and Parliament must amend the Act. Until then, the existing section 16(2)(c) and the case law continue to apply.
  • Final wording of section 16A. The standard of proof (“established through an investigation”), the phrase “knowingly” and the reach to “any antecedent stage” are likely to attract close attention. Industry will want clarity on procedure, such as the stage at which a finding is made and the safeguards of notice and hearing.
  • Interaction with existing provisions. The relationship between section 16A and the existing demand provisions (sections 73 and 74), as well as the burden of proof under section 155, will need to be understood when the final text emerges.
  • Transition and retrospectivity. The note does not discuss whether relief will apply to past periods or pending disputes. This is a significant open question for the large body of existing litigation.
  • Drafting points. The note has minor blanks and inconsistencies in its own text, such as an unfilled agenda item number in para 7.1 and the reference to the Punjab and Haryana case both as Shaurya Alloys and Shaurya Metal. These should be cleaned up before the note goes to the Council.

Conclusion

The draft Agenda Note tries to resolve a long-standing tension in GST: protecting the revenue from fraudulent ITC chains without penalising honest buyers for matters beyond their control. Its answer is to move from a payment-based test to a conduct-based test. The recipient need no longer worry about how the supplier funded his tax payment or about defaults further up the chain, but a recipient who knowingly takes part in fake invoicing will lose credit under a dedicated provision, after investigation.

If adopted in this form, the changes would align GST with the principles of the VAT-era decisions, the Gujarat and Punjab and Haryana High Courts and the Axel Kittel doctrine. For businesses, the practical message is to keep an eye on the proposal as it develops and, in the meantime, to build strong documentation and supplier due diligence, since the proposed regime will reward those who can show they were genuine.

Disclaimer: This article is based on a draft agenda note and is for general information only. It is not legal or tax advice. Readers should consult a qualified professional and refer to the final law once enacted.

Loading Viewer...

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest